The Titans are less than a week away from a win-and-you’re-in-the-playoffs matchup with division rival Houston. They are about three months away from free agency and four months away from the 2020 NFL Draft. With so much football still left, roster changes are still uncertain at this point.
On the heels of a 38-28 loss to the New Orleans Saints, however, the Titans organization and general manager Jon Robinson may have witnessed a game that could be seen as a microcosm of the 2019 season. Tennessee played pretty well overall, and displayed some major improvements when compared to seasons past. At the same time, there were obvious holes that may very well have doomed the Titans to lose their final home game of the season. As the Titans move forward, and we draw nearer to the offseason, here are a list of position needs that became more evident in the loss to the Saints:
#1 OUTSIDE LINEBACKER/EDGE RUSHER
This is one area where common sack statistics do not tell the whole story. The Titans defense is currently tied for 13th in sacks. Tennessee’s Harold Landry has also netted nine sacks on the year, tying him with San Francisco’s Nick Bosa for the 20th most sacks in the league.
And yet, the Titans have struggled to generate a consistent pass rush. According to Pro Football Reference the Titans defense pressures opposing quarterbacks on only 20% of dropbacks, ranking them 25th in the league in that category.
And in watching the game against the Saints, a casual observer could see this problem manifesting itself again. There were moments where Drew Brees was able to survey the field and connect on long passes, thanks in no small part to the Saints pass protection. Even though the Saints only converted four of its 12 3rd-down attempts, the Saints offense found a way to extend drives. When the Saints needed a big play, the Titans pass rush was seemingly negated and Brees was able to find an open receiver.
If the Titans want to take the next step from an above-average team to elite, this has to change. Adding a reliable, consistent edge rusher (along with Landry and Cameron Wake) can help the Titans secondary to slow down opposing passing offenses.
Speaking of the Titans secondary…
#2 CORNERBACK
It’s difficult for any team to mount a formidable pass defense when two of its top three corners are out with injury. That’s exactly where the Titans have found themselves in the last couple of games with Malcolm Butler being on IR and Adoree Jackson missing time due to a knee injury.
And so the Titans have had to cover arguably two of the league’s best receivers (Houston Texans DeAndre Hopkins and New Orleans Saints Michael Thomas) in that time frame without Butler or Jackson. Both of those receivers combined for 18 receptions, 255 yards receiving and one touchdown against the Titans.
Injuries are an inevitable part of the NFL and they plague every team in the league, especially as the season wears on. But as the league is still very much a passing league, cornerback depth is not a luxury, it’s a necessity. And frankly, neither Butler or Jackson have exactly played like a top-10 corner during their respective times in Nashville.
On top of that, the Titans will have five cornerbacks whose contracts expire at the end of the 2019-20 league year (Logan Ryan, Leshaun Sims, Chris Milton, Trumaine Brock and Tye Smith.) Ryan has easily been the Titans most consistent corner this season, and bringing him back seems like a no-brainer. After Ryan though, everyone else’s time in Nashville is definitely up for debate.
Adding a true lockdown corner would be huge for this defense. In fact, an arguement could be made that it’s even more important than landing a pass rusher.
Any NFL franchise would openly welcome the addition of a star corner, and obviously the Titans would be no different. But even if the Titans’ newly added corner only played up to the same level of Butler or Jackson, Tennessee would still love the added depth.
#3 WIDE RECEIVER
A.J. Brown’s receiving performance against the Saints certainly won’t wow anyone (one reception for 34 yards), but there’s no denying how talented the rookie from Ole Miss is. For years the Titans have looked for a receiver like Brown. And now that they have one, they need to add someone opposite of him to help him out.
The addition of Adam Humphries has been a good one when he’s healthy. Corey Davis, on the other hand, has just not been consistent enough since he was the #5 overall pick in the 2017 NFL Draft. His performance against the Saints (three receptions for 40 yards) has become more of a pattern than an anomaly.
Sure, injuries throughout his career may have slowed his development. But there’s no other way to describe his play other than disappointing.
The good news for Davis (and the Titans) is that he still has plenty of time to turn that around. As a former first-round pick, Davis received a four-year deal with a fifth-year option. Davis is only into the third year of his deal, and so he still has time to help prove that he can be another difference maker in this offense. And with Brown sure to draw the attention of the secondary, now is the perfect time for Davis to make the most of his remaining time in Nashville.
That’s not to say Robinson should not add another outside receiver during the offseason. In truth, adding another receiver may help to spark competition for the receiver job opposite of Brown. And that competition might be the very motivation Davis needs to take the next step in his development.
#4 OFFENSIVE TACKLE/GUARD
The Titans allowed five sacks against the Saints and are now tied with the Carolina Panthers and Miami Dolphins for the most sacks allowed with 56.
Yikes.
This is particularly disturbing given how much attention, draft picks and money the Titans have used to fix the offensive line since Jon Robinson’s arrival in Tennessee. In fact, Robinson’s first draft selection as the Titans general manager was offensive tackle Jack Conklin. And yet Robinson opted to not pick up Conklin’s fifth-year option back in May.
On one hand, Robinson declining the option should not come as too much of a surprise given the Titans struggles with protecting quarterbacks. But on the other, Conklin is by no means the only one who deserves blame on the line.
But letting Conklin, whose contract expires at the end of the league year, walk away would only add another need for Robinson to address this offseason. And thanks to the Ryan Tannehill trade last offseason, the Titans have one less draft pick in the 4th round. With less draft capital, it’s possible Robinson would not want to create another need for his team.
Still, there are many questions that Robinson will have to answer. Has Conklin done enough to earn an extension? If so, how much are the Titans willing to give him? If not, what is Tennessee’s plan to replace the former first-rounder from Michigan State?
Even if the Titans retain Conklin, the addition of another offensive tackle is certainly not out of the question. Adding competition on the offensive line may help to improve pass protection, something that simply must improve in 2020.
#5 RUNNING BACK
Derrick Henry is undeniably deserving of a new contract in Tennessee. There will be no advocating of moving on from Henry here. He has been the focal point of the offense for years, and should continue to be for years to come.
So why list running back here, then?
Because, as was evident against the Saints, when the Titans do not have a physical, power back available, the entire dynamic of the offense changes.
The Titans want to ground it out with Henry, giving him 20+ touches a game. Doing so wears down a defense over the course of a game which, in turn, helps the passing game.
With Henry being a power back who’s not afraid of taking on defenders, it’s reasonable to expect some nagging injuries along the way. And if/when it does happen, the Titans need to have another back who can give them a similar physical presence at running back to help continue wearing defenses down.
If the Titans had such a back against the Saints, the outcome may or may not have changed. But one thing is for certain: The game would have looked very different.
With one regular-season game remaining, the Titans playoff hopes are still very much within reach. No matter how far the Titans go in the 2019-20 season, addressing these holes is sure to help the Titans go even farther in the postseason.